Incentives matter, Sammy Hagar edition

Why do we have traffic cops?

Silly blogger!  They keep us safe on the roads!

Ah, of course; how foolish of me.  Er, how do they keep us safe?

By enforcing traffic laws, of course!

Naturally.  Uh, so traffic laws keep us safe, when enforced?

Of course they do!  They keep people from driving on the wrong side of the road, or speeding through residential neighbourhoods and plowing through crowds of schoolchildren!

Gotcha.  So traffic laws keep us safe by prohibiting dangerous behaviour, and traffic cops punish and deter dangerous behaviour from drivers by enforcing them.

And then this happened.

The 55 mph speed limit was a vain attempt by the Federal government to reduce gasoline consumption; initially passed in the 1974 Emergency Highway Energy Conservation Act the law was relaxed in 1987 and finally repealed in 1995 allowing states to choose their speed limits. Highways and cars are safer today than in the 1970s and on many highways speed limits were increased to 65 mph. Higher speed limits are often safer because what is worse than speed is variable speed, some people driving fast and some driving slow. When the speed limit is set too low you get lots of people who safely break the law and a few law-abiders who make the roads more dangerous.

Alex Tabarrok links to a report from John Carr on an interstate in MA:

Route 3 was completely rebuilt a decade ago. The design speed for the project was 110 km/h (68 mph). The design speed is like a warranty: nothing in the road design requires a driver to go slower than 68 mph, not even on a wet road at night (the design conditions).

The average speed is not far from the design speed. The 85th percentile speed, which is supposed to be used for setting speed limits, is around 75 mph. A little over by my measurement, which found 1% compliance with the speed limit.

Eventually the absurdity of the 55 mph speed limit sunk in and in 2006 MassHighway traffic engineers recommended a speed limit increase. State Police vetoed the change, preferring the 99% violation rate that let them write tickets at will. Police have no legal role in setting speed limits. Somebody in the Romney administration weighed the risk of losing ticket revenue against the risk of being blamed for accidents. Police won.

After engineers lost that fight people began to worry about the high accident rate on Route 3. The state hired a consultant to do a Road Safety Audit. The consultant’s report blamed the low speed limit, among other factors, for the high crash rate. The report explicitly recommended raising the speed limit.

Three years later, state officials have not followed the advice of their engineers, their consultant, or 100,000 drivers per day. State police are still out there running speed traps and helping keep the road as dangerous and profitable as they can.

So here’s the problem: The MA state government has no particular incentive to build and run safe roads.  They do have an incentive to have the State Police write a lot of speeding tickets, and they do have an incentive to avoid taking steps that appear to be risky, like raising the speed limit on Route 3.  But they don’t gain anything tangible when someone has a quick and safe trip along a state highway, and they don’t lose anything tangible when someone crashes on Route 3.  We like to believe that they’ll pursue highway safety out of their sense of obligation to the people they serve and their own inherent goodness, but it’s plenty obvious that that is not enough.


0 Responses to “Incentives matter, Sammy Hagar edition”

  1. Leave a Comment

Leave a reply; use raw HTML for markup. Please blockquote quotations from the post or other comments.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

anarchocapitalist agitprop

Be advised

I say fuck a lot



Statistics FTW


%d bloggers like this: